Is Hydroxyapatite Safe? What You Need To Know

Is Hydroxyapatite Safe? What You Need To Know

Amidst the sea of oral care products, one ingredient is making waves for its promise to reinvent the way we protect our teeth: hydroxyapatite. Often touted as a natural alternative to fluoride, this mineral-based substance could be the key to unlocking a brighter and healthier smile—without relying on traditional fluoride toothpaste.

With years of experience in dental health and passionate research into bioactive materials, I've navigated through numerous scientific studies and clinical findings to demystify hydroxyapatite's role in oral wellness.

Hydroxyapatite isn't just another buzzword in the world of dentistry; it's an integral part of what keeps our teeth strong – naturally occurring in both bones and pearly whites. Safety concerns loom with any new product on the market, but current evidence suggests that hydroxyapatite may offer effective cavity prevention while being safe enough even for kids who haven't mastered spitting out toothpaste yet.

Keep reading as we delve into what makes this biocompatible material tick—your smile may thank you for it! Get ready to uncover some toothy truths.

Understanding Hydroxyapatite: Nano vs Micro Particles

"Nano and micro particles refer to the size and form of hydroxyapatite, with nano particles being much smaller in size than micro particles."

What are Nano and Micro Particles

Nano and micro particles are tiny bits of material. Nano particles are super small, less than 100 nanometers wide. To picture how tiny that is, a human hair is about 80,000 nanometers thick! Micro particles are a bit bigger than nano ones but still very small.

They can be up to 1000 nanometers across.

These tiny pieces matter in things like toothpaste because they can do jobs that bigger pieces can't. For example, nano hydroxyapatite is used in some toothpastes to help fix damaged spots on teeth and make them stronger.

This works well because the particles are so small they can fit into tiny cracks in tooth enamel. But their size also has people worried about safety since these little bits could move around inside your body in ways we don’t fully understand yet.

Size and Form: Why It Matters

Understanding the difference between nano and micro particles leads us to another important factor: the size and shape of these tiny pieces. In oral care, like when we use toothpaste, how big or small these particles are can really change things.

Tiny nano-hydroxyapatite particles are much smaller than micro-sized ones. Because they're so small, they can move in different ways inside our bodies.

The shape of hydroxyapatite matters too. Some shapes might be harder for our bodies to handle. Not knowing if there are round or jagged edges on the particles could cause worry about safety.

Companies don't always tell us about the size and form of hydroxyapatite in their products. This missing information makes some people wonder if it's okay to use them every day for brushing teeth or in mouthwash.

What are the concerns with hydroxyapatite?

Studies have shown concerns about hydroxyapatite's impact on organs in animal studies and potential DNA damage related to particle size.

Animal Study Findings on Organ Impact

Tests on animals show that nano hydroxyapatite might not be completely safe. Some studies found damage to important body parts like lungs, liver, and kidneys in animals given this substance.

This could mean trouble for how these organs work.

Not just that, but high doses of nano hydroxyapatite made some animal's bodies respond with swelling and harm to cells. These tiny bits disturbed red blood cells and platelets too, which are crucial for health.

They even caused DNA changes in human cells, which can be a big worry because DNA tells our bodies how to function properly.

DNA Damage Concerns and Particle Size

Moving on from the effects on organs, there's worry about how tiny hydroxyapatite particles might harm our DNA. Some studies discovered that nano hydroxyapatite can hurt human cells by damaging their DNA.

This is a big deal because damage to DNA can lead to serious health problems.

The size of these particles plays a huge part in this concern. Companies often don't tell us if they use nano or micro-sized hydroxyapatite in their products. This lack of information makes it hard for people to know what they're putting in their mouths and whether it could be risky.

We need clear facts about the particle sizes used in oral care items to make safe choices for our teeth and body.

Regulatory Stance on Hydroxyapatite

Europe banned hydroxyapatite due to concerns over its safety, but the FDA has approved its use in oral care products.

Why did Europe ban hydroxyapatite?

Europe banned hydroxyapatite due to concerns about potential harmful effects on organs. Animal studies showed troubling impacts, leading the European Commission Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety to recommend against its use.

Specifically, there were worries about nano-hydroxyapatite being absorbed through the skin and accumulating in various organs, prompting the European Union to prohibit its use in cosmetics over fears of health risks.

Despite these measures, nano-HA is still facing a Euro ban because of ongoing apprehensions about tiny particles being absorbed through the skin and building up in organs.

FDA Approval

The FDA has not approved the use of nano hydroxyapatite in consumer products yet. There is ongoing debate and a need for further research on the safety of using nano hydroxyapatite in consumer products.

Companies using hydroxyapatite have been criticized for not disclosing particle size and shape, and the FDA's regulatory stance on nano hydroxyapatite remains unclear at present.

Comparing Hydroxyapatite and Fluoride Toothpaste

Hydroxyapatite toothpaste has been shown to be effective in cavity prevention and reducing tooth sensitivity, while also providing a different taste and texture experience for consumers compared to fluoride toothpaste.

Efficacy in Cavity Prevention and Tooth Sensitivity

Hydroxyapatite has been shown to be effective in preventing cavities and reducing tooth sensitivity. Studies indicate that it aids in the remineralization of initial decay and is even more effective than fluoride.

This makes it a promising alternative for maintaining good oral health, especially for those with sensitive teeth or prone to cavities. Its ability to help rebuild tooth enamel also contributes to its efficacy in cavity prevention.

Furthermore, hydroxyapatite has shown potential in addressing tooth sensitivity by forming a protective layer over exposed dentin, providing relief from discomfort.

Consumer Experiences: Taste and Texture

Considering the potential health benefits of nano-hydroxyapatite in treating tooth sensitivity, its use in toothpaste could improve consumer experiences. The particle size and shape of hydroxyapatite play a crucial role in determining taste and texture, which impacts the overall satisfaction of consumers using such dental products.

As it has been used for over four decades in dental care, there are indications that its inclusion can enhance the taste and texture of toothpaste, providing an important aspect to consider for both producers and consumers alike.

The safety debate surrounding nano-hydroxyapatite's usage requires further research; this consideration directly affects how consumers experience products containing this ingredient.

Do dentists recommend hydroxyapatite?

Many dentists recommend hydroxyapatite for its ability to combat tooth decay and remineralize teeth. Nano-Hydroxyapatite is used in dentistry and dental products, known to make teeth feel stronger, smoother, and healthier.

It is a fluoride alternative that has been reported to be effective in preventing cavities and addressing tooth sensitivity. Moreover, it is considered non-toxic and may offer additional benefits such as bone growth support.

The use of hydroxyapatite in oral care aligns with the aim of promoting overall oral hygiene.



In conclusion, while hydroxyapatite shows promise in oral care, there are concerns about the safety of nano particles. The European Commission's findings on potential organ effects and DNA damage warrant further examination.

Although generally safe and effective for tooth remineralization and cavity prevention, careful consideration is essential before widespread use as a toothpaste ingredient. As research continues to unfold, it's crucial to weigh both the benefits and potential risks associated with hydroxyapatite use.

Previous post Next post